Home › Filament Cost Enclosure

Filament Cost Per Print for Different Enclosure Setups

Quick answer: A 150 g PLA print at about $0.02/g costs roughly $3.00 in filament before failures (estimate; check maker spec). Enclosures mainly change print time and reliability, not grams used, though retries from heat creep or warping can raise total spend. Price filament by mass, then add enclosure benefits as fewer wasted spools.

Enclosure setups can influence the cost of 3D printing, but not in the way you might expect. While enclosures don't change the physical mass of filament used for a 3D model, they can affect print time, which in turn affects electricity costs and overall efficiency. Understanding how enclosures influence filament cost per print is essential for budgeting and optimizing your 3D printing workflow.

How Enclosures Affect Filament Cost

Enclosures are commonly used in 3D printing to improve print quality, reduce warping, and maintain consistent temperatures. However, they do not directly affect the amount of filament used for a given model. The filament mass required for a print is determined by the model's geometry, layer height, and nozzle size, not by whether the printer is enclosed or open.

That said, enclosures can influence print time. Enclosed printers often print slower to maintain temperature stability, which can increase the total time a print takes. While this doesn't change the filament cost, it can increase electricity costs. Understanding this distinction is key to accurate cost estimation.

Worked Example: Calculating Filament Cost for Enclosed vs. Open-Frame Printers

Let's walk through a real-world example to see how filament cost is calculated for a 150g print on both an enclosed and an open-frame printer.

Step 1: Determine Filament Cost Per Gram

Assume you're using a 1.75mm PLA filament. The price per spool is $15 for a 1kg spool.

Filament cost per gram = Spool price / Spool weight in grams
= $15 / 1000g = $0.015/g

Step 2: Calculate Total Filament Cost

Filament cost = Grams used × Cost per gram
= 150g × $0.015/g = $2.25

This is the cost of the filament for the print, regardless of whether the printer is enclosed or open.

Step 3: Consider Print Time and Electricity Cost

Enclosed printers may take longer to complete a print due to slower print speeds. Let's say the enclosed printer takes 10% longer than the open-frame printer.

Print time for open-frame printer = 2 hours
Print time for enclosed printer = 2 hours × 1.10 = 2.2 hours

Now, let's calculate the electricity cost for both setups. Assume the printer uses 100 watts and the electricity rate is $0.12 per kWh.

Electricity cost = (Printer watts / 1000) × Hours × Price per kWh
= (100 / 1000) × 2 × $0.12 = $0.024
= (100 / 1000) × 2.2 × $0.12 = $0.0264

So, the electricity cost for the enclosed printer is slightly higher, but the filament cost remains the same.

Step 4: Total Cost Per Print

Total cost for open-frame printer = $2.25 + $0.024 = $2.274
Total cost for enclosed printer = $2.25 + $0.0264 = $2.2764

As you can see, the difference in total cost is minimal, and the filament cost remains unchanged.

Real-World Scenario: A 200g Print on Enclosed and Open-Frame Printers

Let's take a more complex example. Suppose you're printing a 200g model using a 2.85mm PETG filament. The spool price is $20 for a 1kg spool.

Filament cost per gram = $20 / 1000g = $0.02/g
Filament cost = 200g × $0.02/g = $4.00

Now, let's calculate the electricity cost for both printers. Assume the enclosed printer takes 10% longer than the open-frame printer.

Print time for open-frame printer = 3 hours
Print time for enclosed printer = 3 hours × 1.10 = 3.3 hours

Electricity cost for open-frame printer = (100 / 1000) × 3 × $0.12 = $0.036
Electricity cost for enclosed printer = (100 / 1000) × 3.3 × $0.12 = $0.0396

Total cost for open-frame printer = $4.00 + $0.036 = $4.036
Total cost for enclosed printer = $4.00 + $0.0396 = $4.0396

Again, the difference is minimal, and the filament cost remains the same.

Common Mistakes in Filament Cost Calculations

Assuming Enclosures Increase Filament Use: Enclosures do not increase the amount of filament used for a print. The filament mass is determined by the model, not the printer setup.
Ignoring Electricity Costs: While filament cost is the largest part of the total print cost, electricity costs can add up over time, especially with enclosed printers that take longer to complete prints.
Using Incorrect Density Values: Filament density varies by material. For example, PLA has a density of about 1.24 g/cm³, while PETG has a density of about 1.25 g/cm³. Using the wrong density can lead to incorrect length calculations.
Not Verifying Spool Prices: Spool prices can vary widely depending on the brand and quality of the filament. Always check the spool price on the manufacturer's website or a trusted retailer.
Overlooking Print Time Estimates: Print time is not calculated using a formula. It comes from the slicer estimate, which is based on the model's complexity, layer height, and print speed.

How to Calculate Filament Length from Grams

If you want to know how long a spool of filament will last, you can calculate the length of filament in meters based on its weight and density.

Formula:

Filament length (m) = (Grams used) / (Density (g/cm³) × π × (Diameter (mm)/2)² / 1000)

Example: 1.75mm PLA Filament

Density = 1.24 g/cm³
Diameter = 1.75 mm
Grams used = 1000g

Filament length = 1000 / (1.24 × π × (1.75/2)² / 1000)
= 1000 / (1.24 × π × (0.875)² / 1000)
= 1000 / (1.24 × π × 0.7656 / 1000)
= 1000 / (1.24 × π × 0.0007656)
= 1000 / (0.00297)
≈ 336.7 meters

This matches the commonly cited value that 1kg of 1.75mm PLA filament is about 335 meters.

Electricity Cost Estimation

Electricity cost is a small but important part of the total print cost. It depends on the printer's power consumption, the print time, and the electricity rate in your area.

Example: 100W Printer, 2 Hours, $0.12/kWh

Electricity cost = (100 / 1000) × 2 × $0.12 = $0.024

This is the cost of running the printer for 2 hours. If the print takes longer due to an enclosed setup, the cost will increase slightly.

FAQ

Q: Does using an enclosed printer increase filament cost?
A: No, the filament cost is determined by the model's geometry, not the printer setup. Enclosures may increase print time, which affects electricity costs, but not filament costs.

Q: How do I calculate the length of filament from grams?
A: Use the formula: Filament length (m) = (Grams used) / (Density × π × (Diameter/2)² / 1000). This requires knowing the filament's density and diameter.

Q: What is the average electricity cost for a 3D print?
A: The average electricity cost for a 3D print is around $0.02 to $0.05, depending on the printer's power consumption and the electricity rate in your area.

Q: Can I use the same filament cost calculation for different materials?
A: Yes, as long as you use the correct density for the material. For example, PLA has a density of about 1.24 g/cm³, while PETG has a density of about 1.25 g/cm³.

Q: How does print time affect filament cost?
A: Print time does not affect filament cost directly. However, longer print times can increase electricity costs, which is an important factor in total print cost.

Who This Is Not For

This page is not for users who are looking for health or safety advice related to 3D printing. Filament fumes and fire safety are not discussed here. Always follow the printer and filament maker's ventilation guidance and never leave prints unattended.

This page is also not for users who are looking for product recommendations or specific printer models. It is intended for users who want to understand how enclosure setups affect filament cost and electricity usage.

Internal Links

Final Thoughts

Understanding how enclosure setups affect filament cost is essential for budgeting and optimizing your 3D printing workflow. While enclosures don't change the amount of filament used for a print, they can increase print time, which affects electricity costs. By calculating filament cost and electricity usage accurately, you can make informed decisions about your 3D printing setup.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, feel free to contact us at [CONTACT EMAIL].

Owner: Charland & Co.
Contact: [CONTACT EMAIL]

Try the filament cost calculator · Back to FAQ & guides · Next: Best enclosure LED strip kits